Samuel’s Trip Report – Exploring New York Sports Betting Sites

Sports betting in New York has really taken off, with plenty of online sportsbooks to choose from. Whether you’re just starting out or have been placing bets for years, there’s no shortage of options to explore in the Empire State.

Samuel, our go-to guy for all things betting, is on the move again. This time, he’s checked out the New York sports betting scene. After trying out 24 platforms, he’s picked the ones that stood out with their odds, bonuses, and overall experience. Take a look at what he found below.

In a rush? New York sports betting site Samuel liked the most after 79 hours of research:

BetWhale

• 150% deposit boost
• 25+ sports to bet on
• Loyalty program with cashback
• Same day payouts

Our online sports betting expert Samuel at Northeasttimes rates BetWhale highly for its competitive odds, a wide variety of betting markets, and strong focus on both major and niche sports.

Not exactly what you’re looking for? These sites also passed Samuel’s checks: 

• BetOnline – A solid choice if you’re into parlay bets
• BetUS – In-house TV offering predictions and good bonus bets
• SportsBetting.ag – Stands out for live betting
• MyBookie – Great sportsbook for mobile betting

Why trust us

We’re an independent newspaper with years of reputation on the line.

We hired an iGaming expert, Samuel, to cover the ongoing rise of online gambling websites and present our readers with the safest options while blacklisting the ones that don’t meet his standards.

We sponsor him to travel and write stories for us, testing betting sites and online casinos in different locations where we have readers.

Samuel’s opinion on New York sports betting websites

1. BetWhale – Great NY betting site for football odds and loyalty bonuses

Pros:

• 150% welcome bonus
• 25+ sports to bet on
• Live streaming available
• Loyalty program with cashback
• Same day payouts
• $500 referral bonus

Cons:

• Lacks a reload bonus
• Not the best for props

I found BetWhale to be a solid option for New York sports bettors. It offers a wide range of bets, from NFL points spreads to even chess matches, which definitely kept things interesting.

The interface is simple to navigate, and I had no trouble placing bets on my phone or laptop.

“Signing up took less than a minute, claiming the 150% welcome bonus took even less than that, and this set the tone for an easygoing NY sports betting experience.” 

Their loyalty program is a major draw. It wasn’t complicated to get into, and you don’t need to place massive bets to start reaping the benefits. Once you’re in you get the regular cashback and a few other perks.

The bet limits are pretty flexible, which should work for both casual bettors and those who like to bet bigger. I also liked the option to bet pre-game and in-play, and they offer live streaming for certain events like international soccer matches.

While BetWhale accepts over 10 payment options for deposits, the withdrawal methods seemed a bit limited to me. And the fact that you can’t cash out less than $150 is also a bit disappointing.

Check out BetWhale 

2. BetOnline – Leading New York sportsbook for parlays and early odds

Pros:

• $250 welcome bonus
• Same game parlays
• Parlay boosts
• Earliest betting lines
• Odds boosters

Cons:

• Some transaction fees
• No live streaming

BetOnline has been around for over 25 years and is a major player in New York sports betting. One feature I found particularly interesting is the ability to place same-game parlays, allowing you to build bets around a single game, like a Lakers vs. Clippers matchup.

If your bet exceeds the maximum stake, you can wait for the odds to change and use the re-bet feature to place it again.

“BetOnline offers a range of useful tools and features for sports bettors. High rollers will appreciate the re-bet tool as it lets you place bigger bets even when you think you’re about to be limited.”

The early betting lines give you the chance to place bets before the market adjusts, or at least weigh your options.

While the lack of alternative lines is a bit of a downside and might not sit well with everyone, you can still turn your bets into teasers and if bets, and Round Robins are sometimes available.

While all of that’s amazing, BetOnline does charge some pretty high transaction fees for credit card deposits and payout, so make sure to check the banking section as this might put off a lot of players.

Try BetOnline for yourself

3. BetUS – Exclusive features and generous bonus bets for New Yorkers

Pros:

• 125% welcome bonus
• 25+ years of experience
• BetUS TV feature
• Toll-free phone support
• 300% up to $6,000 referral bonus

Cons: 

• Lack of safer gambling tools
• Occasional slow loading times

BetUS offers some pretty generous bonuses and a few features that caught my attention. One of them is BetUS TV, a show with expert panelists who break down major upcoming sports games. It’s a solid way to get insights before placing your bets.

Another cool feature is The Locker Room, where you can find more analysis, predictions, and betting tips, plus actual picks from the experts.

“I’ve used BetUS TV a lot after signing up. The content is solid – it gives useful insights and makes betting more enjoyable. It’s a nice feature to have.”

As for bonus bets, BetUS offers a 125% matched deposit bonus split across your first three deposits. The only catch is you need to deposit at least $100 to claim it. And that’s quite a catch, if you ask me, as I know most bettors aren’t comfortable getting started with $100.

Get started at BetUS

4. SportsBetting.ag – Great for live betting and for high rollers

Pros: 

• 50% welcome bonus up to $500
• $100 risk-free live bonus bet
• Great odds boosters
• High deposit limits
• 24/7 customer support

Cons: 

• No VIP program
• Some transaction fees

SportsBetting.ag is another well-established betting site that stands out for its live sports wagers. You can bet on over 20 sports in real-time, including NFL and soccer, with markets like the moneyline and point spread.

The interface is easy to navigate, and it’s especially helpful for live betting, where all the necessary information – odds and in-game stats – are right there for you. Plus, I came across a $100 risk-free live bonus bet.

“I tested the live sports betting experience at several sportsbooks, and SportsBetting.ag stood out for its in-play options. I could place bets until the last minute, and the in-play odds seemed consistently better than what I saw elsewhere.” 

Sportsbetting.ag is also known for having high bet limits, which is great for those who like to place larger bets.

Deposit limits are flexible, and if you’re using crypto, you can deposit up to $100,000. While the withdrawal limits are also high, the transaction fees get pretty high for credit cards, similar to what I found at BetOnline.

Explore SportsBetting.ag

5. MyBookie – Great for mobile sports betting and college sports odds

Pros:

• $1,000 welcome bonus
• Excellent mobile betting experience
• Alternative lines available
• Unlimited reload bonuses
• Rewarding VIP program

Cons:

• Limited payment methods
• High minimum deposit for some bonuses

Out of all the mobile sportsbooks I’ve tested, I found MyBookie to be the easiest to use, with a clean design and solid overall functionality.

You can place bets on your mobile device and access the same sports, odds, and markets as desktop users, plus claim the same bonuses around the clock.

“I never had any issues betting on the mobile version of MyBookie. In fact, I probably preferred it. And since I could use the mobile browser, I didn’t have to worry about taking up storage space on my smartphone.” 

MyBookie also offers sports betting contests, including NFL handicapping contests, and gives you access to unlimited 50% reload bonuses. The only downside is the $125 minimum deposit.

For college sports fans, the site covers college football and basketball markets, alternative lines, and futures bets.

I also like that MyBookie features a daily betting news and tips section for college football, along with the option to cash out on bets whenever I want.

Check out MyBookie 

Other NY online sportsbooks Samuel tested that didn’t make his top 5 picks

• BUSR – Good for horse racing, but lacks regular offers
• Wild.io – Great for crypto, but doesn’t accept fiat currencies
• XBet – Good esports market coverage, but it has average bet limits
• Thunderpick – Innovative sportsbook with good features, but posts late lines
• BetAnySports – Good bonuses for betting on US sports, but it has a complex interface

While all the above online sportsbooks I tested are perfectly acceptable and have different strengths, many of them also exclude certain sports bettors. Wild.io, for example, focuses solely on crypto sports bettors.

This went against my overriding mission: to establish a list of the top 5 sportsbooks in the New York online sports betting industry that caters to all types of bettors.

With that in mind, you’ll still find generous welcome bonuses at all the online gambling sites in the top 10, as well as a variety of betting markets and solid odds.

That said, I am committed to updating my rankings whenever online sports betting sites change. If a sportsbook adds a new feature, for example, it could climb a spot or two in my list.

How to know if a NY sports betting site is safe?

The New York sports betting scene is the same as anywhere else – it can be completely safe provided you join legit bookies.

On the other hand, it can be unsafe if you join unreliable New York sports betting sites.

The easiest way to separate the two and enjoy safe sports betting in New York is to sign up with licensed and regulated NY sportsbooks. You’ll find this information on the homepage of any NY sportsbook.

Additionally, the best online betting sites New York has to offer secure their website with SSL encryption, which prevents fraudsters from accessing your information. Again, this information is typically available on the homepage.

Other things to look out for are payment methods. Legit sports betting NYC apps and websites support payment methods you trust, including major credit and debit cards, and popular eWallets like Skrill.

Lastly, you can read existing customer reviews. While these are not always super accurate, they give you solid insights into the reputation of any sportsbook that’s offering sports betting in New York.

Tips for betting at New York online sportsbooks

Sports wagering can be a lot of fun – but it’s much more fun when you know a thing or two.

In this section, I’ll share with New York sports fans my best tips and tricks for online sports betting in NY.

Join multiple sportsbooks

From established New York sportsbooks to brand new sports betting sites, you’ve got lots of choices – so many choices that it’s a smart idea to join different sites.

After all, they’re free to join, and because they offer different bonuses, odds, and betting markets, there’s no reason not to create different accounts.

Claim the bonuses

When you sign up for any sportsbook, the first thing you should do is claim the welcome bonus. If you skip it and make a minimum first deposit that doesn’t meet the requirement for the welcome offer, you’ll miss out on bonus funds that can be used to place bets.

Watch out for odds boosts

All the best online betting sites New York has to offer feature regular odds boosts that ramp up your maximum potential win. They come with no wagering requirements or minimum deposits, and they’re super easy to claim.

Cashout your bets

While I’m not saying you should always cash out, the early cashout tool, which is available at many New York sportsbooks, can be used strategically to your advantage from time to time.

For example, if you’ve placed a five-fold parlay and four legs have won, you might be tempted to cash out for a reduced profit, rather than risk the fifth one losing.

Don’t get caught out by fees

Sports betting New York sites sometimes charge minor fees when you use specific payment methods. To make sure you don’t get caught out, research each payment method to see which ones come with lower fees. As a pro tip, crypto never comes with fees.

Check predictions

A lot of websites on the internet offer picks and predictions from pro handicappers or athletes, and it’s a good idea to check up on them regularly – especially when you’re not too familiar with the sport you want to bet on.

New York sports betting – FAQs

Is mobile sports betting available in New York?

Yes, mobile sports betting is available in New York and there are multiple New York mobile sports betting sites you can join, with all the top sportsbooks letting you play on different devices.

Some sportsbooks have an app you can download and install, but all NY mobile sports betting sites let you access their odds and markets via your mobile browser.

Is online sports betting safe in New York?

Sports betting is safe in New York but it’s important that you sign up to online sportsbooks that are permitted to offer their services in the Empire State.

You must also abide by state laws, such as the minimum age requirement, and check local laws whenever you want to bet in another state, like California betting sites for example.

Can I bet on local sports teams in New York?

Yes, you’re free to bet on who you want in New York, as long as there’s a market for it. This means you can bet on the likes of the New York Giants, the New York Islanders, the New York Rangers, and many other New York sports teams.

What types of bets can I place at online betting sites?

You can place a variety of bets at sportsbooks, including single moneyline, point spread, and total bets. You can bet on props, such as a player hitting a home run in an MLB game, and turn your bets into parlays and teasers.

Futures bets are also available at all the best sports betting sites in New York.

Can I win money from NY sports betting?

Yes, you can win money from sports betting in New York. Many people win money from betting all the time, though very few individuals can make consistent profits over the long term.

This is why it’s better to see sports betting in NYC as fun rather than a way of making money.

What I learned about online casinos from my trip to New York

These are the 10 mobile sportsbooks and websites that I’ve found to be great choices for New York bettors, based on my testing, reviews, and ratings.

Each sportsbook offers competitive odds, a variety of markets, solid bonuses, and reliable payouts. They each have their own strengths that will appeal to different types of bettors.

Whether you’re looking to place larger bets, bet on college sports, or follow the New York Knicks, New York sports betting online has options for everyone.

Whatever you decide, just remember to bet responsibly and enjoy the experience.

DISCLAIMER: The information on this site is for entertainment purposes only. Online gambling comes with risks. There’s no guarantee of financial gain, so you should only gamble with what you can afford to lose.

While gambling can be fun, it can also be addictive. If you or anyone you know suffers from a gambling addiction problem, we recommend you call the National Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700 to speak with an advisor. Please remember that our guides and all gambling sites are 21+. Also, check with local laws if online gambling is legal in your area.

For free online gambling addiction resources, visit these organizations: