Connect with us

NFL

Giants Week 2 report card: Run defense was lousy

Published

on

Giants Week 2 report card: Run defense was lousy

Grading the Giants’ 21-18 Week 2 loss to the Commanders on Sunday:

Offense

This unit had seven possessions and scored three touchdowns.

The problem was, Daniel Jones & Co. were not out there enough.

Jones (16-of-28, 178 yards, 2 TDs, passer rating of 100.0) came up with a strong bounceback from a dreadful opener.

There was actually too much focus on getting rookie Malik Nabers the ball — he was targeted 18 times and finished with 10 catches for 127 yards and his first NFL TD.

Malik Nabers was targeted 18 times during the Giants’ loss to the Commanders on Sept. 15. AP

His drop on the sideline on fourth down with 2:04 left was a killer and he was ticked about it.

Devin Singletary (16-95) found room to run but he had the ball punched out for a fumble to ruin a promising series early in the third quarter, a turnover that led to a Washington field goal.

The line provided solid protection (one sack allowed). Wan’Dale Robinson had a TD catch early in the fourth quarter.

Grade: B

Defense

When you do not give up a touchdown you should win, but not this way.

The Commanders had seven true possessions and made field goals on all seven — no punts.

That meant the time of possession slanted heavily toward Washington: 37:32 to 22:28.

Coordinator Shane Bowen was supposed to fix the run defense, but it was lousy — 215 yards, with Brian Robinson Jr. muscling for 133, averaging 7.8 per rush.

Jayden Daniels was 23-of-29 for 226 as a passer and 10-44 as a rusher.

Brian Robinson Jr. averaged 7.8 yards per carry against the Giants on Sept. 15. Getty Images
Quarterback Jayden Daniels collected 44 of the Commanders’ 215 rushing yards on Sept. 15. Imagn Images

He was accurate and avoided mistakes.

There were five sacks, including two from safety Jason Pinnock.

But Pinnock committed a holding penalty to keep a drive alive and failed to make a play on the ball to allow a 21-yard reception for Zach Ertz.

Rookie CB Dru Phillips looks like a keeper.

Micah McFadden had 12 tackles and one sack in his season debut.

Commanders were 0-for-6 in the red zone but 7-for-14 converting on third down.

Bizarre.

Grade: D

Special teams

Ugh.

Not having an active second place-kicker cost, big time, after Graham Gano pulled his right hamstring chasing down the opening kickoff — after coming into the game with a sore right groin.

If punter Jamie Gillan is not trusted to kick short field goals or extra points he cannot be considered a legitimate option.

Gillan missed badly on his only PAT attempt.

Gillan failed to get the ball into the landing zone on a fourth quarter kickoff, giving Washington the ball on its 40-yard line.

A high-arching Gillan punt in the second quarter for 27 yards needed to get inside the 10-yard line instead of dropping down at the 18.

Giants averaged 26 yards on six punt returns.

Grade: F

Coaching

Brian Daboll said game-day activations are collaborative decisions and added they ultimately fall on him.

He needed to have a second kicker available here.

Daboll as the play-caller on offense might have put too much emphasis on targeting Nabers, as there were only four targets apiece for Darius Slayton and Wan’Dale Robinson.

Daboll won a replay challenge in the first quarter when he disputed a spot, denying the Commanders a first down.

Brian Daboll, pictured Sept. 15, opted to only have one kicker available despite Graham Gano entering with an injury, Getty Images

Midway through the third quarter, Daboll won another challenge contesting a spot for a first down.

The shabby run defense has to greatly trouble Bowen.

Grade: F

Continue Reading