Ice cream shop, former monastery property among sales

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from July 1-8.

During this time period, Craig Moore sold 1016 Rt. 5 and 20, Hanover to Frosty Treat, LLC of Derby for $140,000.

On July 5, Frosty Treat announced on Facebook that the business had a new owner.

The post noted that Frosty Treat has been around for more than 70 years, starting with the Parker family in 1954-58. Moore was the eighth owner of the business, owning it from 1995-2024, the longest of any of the owners.

Chautauqua County sold 3452 Turner Road, Ellicott for $109,900.

“It has been an amazing nearly 30 years and quite a long process to find the perfect fit to continue this legacy — but a great, local family is taking over and we are excited to see what the future holds for Frosty Treat,” the former owner wrote.

The social media post states Frosty Treat is now owned by the Schmidt family.

In a separate sale, some vacant land on Route 5 in the town of Dunkirk that used to house a monastery has been sold.

G.H. Graf Realty Corp. sold 4674 West Lake Road, Dunkirk town to Robert and Bonnie Urbanik for $1.1 million.

There was a sign on the property that labeled it “Lang’s Landing.” A Northern Chautauqua Intermunicipal Local Waterfront Revitalization Program pdf on dunkirkdri.com says Lang’s Landing is a former monastery property and “would be an excellent campground or park.”

No plans have been announced for the property. Graf Realty Corp had owned the land since 1992.

Also during this time period, Chautauqua County sold 3452 Turner Road, Ellicott to Best Adventures, LLC of Jamestown for $109,900.

This is the address of the former Frank W. Bratt Agricultural Center. At one point that building had housed the Cornell Cooperative Extension offices.

CCE relocated to Jamestown Community College’s Katharine Jackson Carnahan Center in December of 2019.

In June of 2023, the Chautauqua County Legislature voted to sell the property.

In 2017, the legislature agreed to sell the property for $75,000 to Jamestown Rental Properties, but the sale fell through.

Then in 2021, the legislature planned to spend $1.1 million to renovate the building, using American Rescue Plan Act funds, which originated from the federal government, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The county ended up nixing that proposal.

Including the previously mentioned sale, from July 1-8 there were nine sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:

– 318 Lakeside Drive, Ellery sold for $999,500.

– 28 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution sold for $584,831.

– Edward and Madaline Barnes sold 342 Central Ave., Fredonia to Hanna Sellari for $407,500.

– 2552 Hanson Road, Gerry sold for $396,000.

– 12 Westbury Center, Ellicott sold for $395,000.

– 28 Casa Bella Drive, Fredonia sold for $290,000.

– 4537 Kortwright Road, Busti sold for $275,000.

– 3539 Rt. 20, Sheridan sold for $262,000.

Overall, from July 1-8 there were 72 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 is as follows:

Samantha Platt sold 20 Sturges St., Jamestown to Bridget Castellano for $35,000.

The Law Department of Chautauqua County sold 3452 Turner Road, Ellicott to Best Adventures, LLC of Jamestown for $109,900.

Elizabeth Goodwin sold 28 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua town, to 28 Elm CHQ, LLC of Winter Park, Fla. for $584,831.

Ashley Kimble sold 10352 Main St., Mina to Steven and Kara Pattison for $240,000.

Peter and Laurie Brown sold 28 Casa Bella Drive, Fredonia to Christopher and Megan Reilly for $290,000.

Craig Moore sold 1016 Rt. 5 and 20, Hanover to Frosty Treat, LLC of Derby for $140,000.

Rebecca Hubbard and Grant Gabel sold 8 Hickory St., Silver Creek to Rachel Czech for $67,000.

The executor of the Estate of Lonzo H. Hawkins sold 619 Pine Ridge Road, Busti to Abraham and Sarah Byler for $53,000.

Charles Pierce and Norman Struzynski sold two parcels on Chautauqua Road, Fredonia to Marc Pacos for $30,000.

Brandon and Julie Heitzenrater sold 2397 Fisher Hill Road, Poland to Brian and Tiffany Brinkman for $225,000.

Leonard Smith sold 945 Central Ave., Dunkirk to Carrie Strawder for $135,000.

Tracy Harrington sold 17 Kingsbury St., Jamestown to Samantha and Sam Robinson IV for $33,000.

New Direction IRA, Inc. sold 625 Prendergast Ave., Jamestown to 176 6th Ave, LLC of Jamestown for $5,000.

Edward and Madaline Barnes sold 342 Central Ave., Fredonia to Hanna Sellari for $407,500.

Michael Adams sold 304 Foote Ave., Jamestown to Christopher and Mackenzie Russell for $45,000.

Rory and Dina Holmberg sold 130 Midgley St., Jamestown to Rebecca Voty for $160,000.

Mark and Toni Paup sold 318 Lakeside Drive, Ellery to Frank and Dawn Schossler for $999,500.

Daniel Haymes sold a parcel on Timbercreek Drive, North Harmony to Andrew and Tracy Hatton for $30,000.

Ashlie Walker sold 124 East St. Sherman to Braden Cook and Lauren Constantino for $174,500.

Judy Cramer sold 3539 Rt. 20, Sheridan to Niagara Mohawk Power Corp. for $262,000.

Chad and Nicholas Velk sold 18 Point Drive West, Dunkirk to Ryan Clark for $145,200.

Michael and Tabatha Peterson sold 322 Baker St., Jamestown to Robin Knepshield for $133,000.

Jose Vazquez sold 527 Deer St., Dunkirk to Dunkirk Home Rentals, LLC of Dunkirk for $40,000.

Justin Mindzak sold 46 Holmes Place, Fredonia to Judy Cramer for $184,900.

The executors of the Last Will and Testament of Nancy Knight sold 9650 Wilson Road, Pomfret to Michael Marshman for $149,000.

Curtis Thompson sold 49 Collins Ave., Jamestown to Ashley Anderson for $130,000.

Nancy Frederick sold 12 Westbury Center, Ellicott to Jimmy La and Kim Bui for $395,000.

Trustees of the Breon Family 2019 Revocable Trust sold 44 Spring St., Westfield to Mitchell and Lottie Abers for $186,250.

Lou Ann Coughlin sold 544 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown to Curtis W. Thompson for $50,000.

The executor of the Estate of Audrey L. Shade sold 3022 North Road, Mina to Victoria Neckers for $242,000.

SRM Real Estate Holdings, LLC sold five parcels on West Lake Road and Lake Shore Drive West in both the town and city of Dunkirk to Gap Land, LLC of Amherst for $191,500.

Marilyn Pratt sold 6 Ellis Ave., Jamestown to Paul and Diane Osborn for $140,000.

The administrator of the Last Will and Testament of Richard Monfort sold 106 Willard St., Jamestown to Thomas Bailey Jr. for $21,500.

The executor of the Estate of E. Eugene Price sold 4931 Main St., Ellery to International Kiosk Systems, LLC of Warren, Pa. for $127,000.

G.H. Graf Realty Corp. sold 4674 West Lake Road, Dunkirk town to Robert and Bonnie Urbanik for $1.1 million.

Christine Cayo, Sandra Zeller, Susan Pakiela, and James Pakiela sold 11 parcels on East Lake Road, Ripley to William and Catherine Stimmel for $65,000.

Randy and Beth Carlson sold 2552 Hanson Road, Gerry to Brandon and Julia Heitzenrater for $396,000.

Robert and Lynne Doyle sold 4537 Kortwright Road, Busti to Douglas Baker and Sarah Kavala for $275,000.

Joel, Jeffrey, John and Josephine Borrello sold 2 Sunset Drive, Pomfret to Damyen Geiger and Lauren Cicero for $210,000.

Jamestown Urban Renewal Agency sold 33 Countryview Estates Subdivision Phase III, Jamestown to Paul and Linda Nelson for $10,500.

Pamela Mansfield sold 5604 Route 83, Ellington to Yvette Keefe for $100,000.

De Forest and Joyce Warn sold 6 North Meadow Lake, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Ashley Gustafson and Katie Grace for $141,000.

Samuel McCrimmon and Lisa Debellis sold 467 Mohawk St., Clymer to Natalie Rickard and Bradyn Pavelka for $112,500.

A referee for Taylor Rowe sold 605 Roosevelt Ave., Dunkirk to 716 & Beyond, Inc. and Crestpoint Corporation for $100,600.

The executors for the Estate of Jacquelyn A. Darling sold 6 Mattison St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Michael and Chelsea Stahlman for $170,000.

Edmund Kaczmarek sold 1180 Hopper Road, Hanover to Mark and Michelle Kaczmarek for $70,000.

Lorraine Nardone sold 2169 Thornton Road, Charlotte to Christopher and Krista Sandy for $145,000.

Alice Hodge sold 9606 Lamberton Road, Pomfret to Mark and Kerry Milliman for $145,000.