New York Sports Betting Sites (2024): 10 Best NY Sportsbooks

As any real New Yorker can tell you, betting on sports is one of the city’s proudest traditions. From Arnold Rothstein to Bumpy Johnson, sports betting has deep roots in the city’s history.

Whether you love betting on the Knicks, Giants, Mets, or anyone else, you can do it easily at the best New York sports betting sites – and take advantage of some of the best odds while at it.

If you’re just getting started, BetOnline is the reigning champ providing the widest range of markets, the best bonuses, and fantastic live betting tools.

But there are plenty of other options on deck, so stay tuned, as the best online betting sites in New York are coming right up.

Best New York Sports Betting Sites

Heads up about our links! Adblock might get confused so please disable it if you have any issues.

These New York sportsbooks all meet the quota for markets, security, and payouts. And, they all excel in their own specific areas. Before you pick one to sign up for, make sure to check out our reviews and find out a little more about each of them.

1. BetOnline – Best New York Sports Betting Site Overall

Pros:

• Highly detailed sportsbook all round
• Up to $1,000 welcome bonus
• Over 25 years of experience
• Most payouts processed in minutes
• 25% sports reload bonus

Cons:

• Live streams not available for all games
• Limited eWallet payment methods

Sports betting in NY is done right at BetOnline. Their 25+ years of experience becomes immediately apparent with a quick look at the sportsbook, bonuses, and customer support service.

New York Betting Markets & Live Tools: 5/5

You’d be hard-pressed to find an online sports betting market that BetOnline doesn’t offer odds on. This is one of the most comprehensive sportsbooks in New York, and across the US for that matter.

Whether it’s pro or college sports, something international, or even something outside of sports like financial or political markets, BetOnline has it covered in a lot of depth and with competitive odds to boot.

The live betting tools add more excitement to an overall experience. New York bettors can enjoy live streams or dynamic live graphics, with the option to bet on events in real time and cash out instantly.

Bonus Offers: 4.9/5

Use the code BET1000 as you make your first deposit at BetOnline to get it matched 50% up to $1,000. A very strong welcome offer indeed, and it comes with a pretty fair rollover of 10x.

And there’s more. BetOnline also offers an excellent 25% sports reload bonus on all qualifying deposits to those who use the code LIFEWEEK15 (although this code will change week in, week out, so make sure to check the promo page to find out what the latest one is).

As if that wasn’t enough, there’s also the VIP Rewards program where players can pick up all kinds of extra perks like cashbacks and prioritized withdrawals when they work their way through the ranks by placing sports bets and playing casino games.

Payout Options & Speed: 4.8/5

Most payouts at BetOnline are processed within minutes, which is as fast as it gets in the New York sports betting industry.

We can’t give the full marks for this category though, as BetOnline charges a fee for credit card deposits which might be a little frustrating for some.

There are a few ways around this including MoneyGram and a handful of cryptocurrencies such as Ethereum and Litecoin, although we’d ideally have liked to have seen a few more eWallets to help players avoid the card fee.

Final Score: 4.9/5

Online betting sites in New York don’t get better than BetOnline. If it wasn’t for the credit card fees, this site would’ve been looking at an absolutely perfect score.

2. BetWhale – Best Bonuses of All Online Betting Sites in New York

Pros:

• 125% up to $1,250 bonus
• 9 crypto banking options
• Phone support available
• Payouts processed in minutes
• 50% Daily Boost offer

Cons:

• Could have more props
• Website feels a little dated

There’s nothing quite like a good welcome bonus, and the best place to get one in New York is BetWhale.

New York Betting Markets & Live Tools: 4.8/5

BetWhale players will be able to bet on everything from Aussie Rules football to table tennis and a whole lot of markets within each sport.

There aren’t quite as many niche sports to choose from but most of the options New York sports bettors fancy are covered very well. Football, basketball, and tennis betting options are all available.

Betting live isn’t quite as immersive as it is at BetOnline though. BetWhale covers a huge range of markets, but placing in-play bets is a little slower and the website design feels somewhat dated – but nothing too major that can interfere with your betting process.

Bonus Offers: 4.9/5

We have no doubt that BetWhale’s welcome bonus is the best for NY players right now. It’s a generous 125% match deposit of up to $1,250 and gets unlocked after you make a payment of $50 or more.

You won’t have to play through a high rollover to cash out any funds you’ve won from this offer. The wagering requirements are set at 10x which is an industry average.

After you’re finished with this offer, you can come back for a handful of extra bonus bets and matched deposits like a 50% Daily Boost offer with the code WINSTREAK. Not bad!

Payout Options & Speed: 4.8/5

There are 9 cryptocurrencies to deposit with at BetWhale, including Bitcoin, Litecoin, Dogecoin, XRP, and Tether. That surely is a lot of choice for a sports betting site.

Payouts with digital coins are typically processed in several minutes which makes BetWhale one of the fastest-payout sports betting sites in New York.

If you’d rather avoid crypto, there are still a few extra options like PayPal, Neosurf, and the classic debit or credit cards.

Final Score: 4.8/5

The banking and bonus sides of things at BetWhale are somehow better than BetOnline, so if BetWhale was to improve on its live betting tools and include more niche sports, it might well have clinched the top spot.

3. Everygame – Best NY Sports Betting Site for Prop Bets

Pros:

• Detailed markets for each sport
• Lots of live graphics
• Futures markets far in advance
• Low rollover on $500 bonus
• 10+ payment methods

Cons:

• 48+ hours for payouts
• Mobile live betting isn’t great

Props betting fans rejoice – Everygame offers highly detailed markets for each and every sport, with hundreds of props to choose from on NBA, NHL, and NHL games.

New York Betting Markets & Live Tools: 4.7/5

Everygame covers every professional sport from around the world very extensively. No matter whether you want to bet on the MLS or the Japanese or Korean leagues, you can curate your bet well for every single game.

As well as that, players will be able to get odds on the outcome of whole seasons far in advance thanks to quality season betting. If you think you can call the winner of the World Series ahead of time, go for it at Everygame.

It’s not just about baseball though. Everygame covers all of New York’s favorite sports well, including basketball and football. For all of these sports, the live betting tools are pretty good and the site provides plenty of graphics and data.

Bonus Offers: 4.9/5

You could get an impressive 100% up to $500 bonus to use on your first payment at the Everygame sportsbook when you use the promo code WELCOME500.

The rollover for this offer is only 8x, so it’s going to be much easier to play through it than at many other online sportsbooks in New York.

Alternatively, you could use the code CRYPTO1K to get 50% up to $1,000 if you use crypto for your first payment.

Payout Options & Speed: 4.6/5

There are over 10 ways to pay at Everygame, including Bitcoin, VISA, and a handful of eWallets. So, even the most pretentious gamblers will find something to their liking.

Payouts are typically delivered in around 48 hours, but they are not processed on weekends, so if you choose to cash out on Friday or late on Thursday then you’re going to have to wait till the following week, which might be slightly inconvenient.

Final Score: 4.7/5

Baseball fans will find a home at Everygame but you don’t necessarily have to be an MLB betting pro to get the best out of this awesome bookmaker – there are many other features to take advantage of.

4. Sportsbetting.ag – Best New York Sports Betting Site for Live Wagering

Pros:

• Fantastic new website design
• Top mobile live betting tools
• 60% Parlay Power Up offer
• Fast withdrawals
• Over 30 sports to bet on

Cons:

• Less extensive eSports betting coverage
• Higher minimum deposit for bonuses

Sportsbetting.ag offers the best mobile sports betting app in New York right now, packed with great live betting tools and fantastic bonuses.

New York Betting Markets & Live Tools: 4.8/5

This New York sportsbook is somewhat notorious for its attention to detail for betting markets with well over 20 sports covered and a lot of events within each of them.

That being said, there’s less coverage of eSports here than at some of the other New York state sports betting sites but you can still opt for League of Legends, Dota 2, Call of Duty, and several other games.

All of this can be enjoyed in fine style through the fantastic new Sportsbetting.ag desktop and mobile sites. Both of them underwent a massive rebranding recently and are much more pleasing to the eye. The live betting tools are top-tier on all devices.

Fun Fact: Sportsbetting.ag is also one of the best NY poker sites.

Bonus Offers: 4.5/5

You could get your first two Sportsbetting.ag deposits doubled up to $500 each with the bonus code DOUBLEUP.

The downside to this bonus is that you’ll need to make a minimum deposit of $100 to claim it, and that’s going to rule out a fair few players who don’t want to be spending that kind of money.

On a positive note, we liked the Parlay Power Up offer where players can boost their parlay odds up to 60%, and the 25% sports betting reload bonus. All in all, there are plenty of ways for you to boost your bankroll.

Payout Options & Speed: 4.6/5

This New York sportsbook supports some of the most popular banking options including cryptocurrencies (like Bitcoin and Litecoin), MoneyGram, Visa, and a few others

Payouts are processed in just minutes with cryptos and they come with no fees. If you opt for something else, you might have to wait a bit more.

Final Score: 4.6/5

It’s quite hard to find an enjoyable live betting experience sometimes but Sportsbetting.ag has had no trouble with creating one whatsoever.

5. Wild.io – Best New York Sportsbook for Crypto Bettors

Pros:

• Fast in-play betting
• 9 crypto payment methods
• Loads of live streams for eSports
• Instant payouts
• $20 free bet every day

Cons:

• Less detailed in-game sports markets sometimes
• Lower max deposit for welcome bonus

A lot of people believe that crypto is the future of sports betting and in that sense, Wild.io is very much ahead of the curve.

New York Betting Markets & Live Tools: 4.6/5

It tends to be the case that crypto and eSports go together well, and this is backed up by the huge range of eSports betting markets at Wild.io. Tons of games are covered here, like FIFA, Call of Duty, and League of Legends.

You’ll be able to watch most of these eSports matches and bet on them live as well. The live betting tools are quick and responsive, and you’ll get consistently competitive odds.

But the chance to do that in real-world sports is a bit more limited. The market coverage for sports is good, although the actual in-game markets for some sports aren’t so detailed.

Bonus Offers: 4.5/5

You could get a 100% match deposit of up to $200 when you first sign up at Wild.io. It’s not as much cash as some of our other top picks but we always love having extra money on the side.

Plus, players can get an additional $20 free bet every single day, which keeps things super exciting.

Payout Options & Speed: 4.7/5

You can choose from 9 different cryptocurrencies to place your deposits at Wild.io, including Cardano, Ripple, and Tether. Withdrawals are processed pretty quickly and you’ll get your money in an average of 5-10 minutes – faster than most Bitcoin sports betting sites.

Keep in mind that since this is a crypto-only New York sportsbook, you won’t be able to make deposits and withdrawals with fiat options.

Final Score: 4.6/5

Wild.io’s modern take on sports betting is going to turn a lot of heads and we’re confident that it deserves its spot in our top five for that reason.

How We Picked the Best Sports Betting Sites in New York

New York Betting Markets & Live Tools

Every New York online sports betting site needs to have a wide selection of markets for the state’s favorite sports like baseball and basketball. But it’s also good to see coverage of more niche sports and non-sports markets, as well as quality live betting setups.

Bonus Offers

Almost every legal sports betting site in New York will have a welcome bonus of some variety, so we’ve been comparing the offers based on the amount and the fairness of the terms and conditions. We gave higher points to NY sportsbook promos with low wagering requirements.

Payout Options & Speed

The best betting sites in New York offer players a wide range of options for deposits and withdrawals. More importantly, they process payouts in a reasonable timeframe, so players don’t have to wait too long to receive their winnings.

We’ve used the same ranking criteria for picking the best sports betting sites in Missouri.

Why is BetOnline the Best New York Sports Betting Site?

There’s no better site for sports betting in New York than BetOnline. Here’s a reminder of the factors that led us to come to that decision:

 

• Fantastic Bonus: A 50% match up to a $1,000 welcome bonus for all new BetOnline players is very impressive indeed. Plus, it comes with fair terms and conditions to make it easier for players to cash out any winnings they’ve generated from it.

• Tons of Markets: Pretty much every sports event you could possibly want to bet on is available with competitive odds at BetOnline. Whether it’s a baseball game right here in New York or a curling match on the other side of the world, the site has got you covered.

• Excellent User Interface: The beautiful design of BetOnline on both mobile and desktop devices combined with the fantastic live betting tools, creates one of the most exciting betting experiences we’ve ever come across.

• Speedy Payouts: Most payouts at BetOnline will be processed in a few minutes – you can say goodbye to days of waiting for your funds to arrive.

New York Online Sports Betting vs Retail Sports Betting

It’s the big battle: online sports betting or retail sportsbooks? We’re going to side with online on this one for the following reasons:

 

• More Competitive Odds: NY sports betting sites strive to offer competitive odds, often surpassing those found at traditional brick-and-mortar sportsbooks. This ensures that you get the best value for your bets and encourages healthy competition among operators.

• Enhanced Live Betting Features: With advanced live betting tools, you can join the action like never before. Enjoy live streams, dynamic graphics, and the ability to place bets in real time.

• Bonus Offers: Another way for sportsbooks to bring in new players is with bonus offers, so you’re going to find a lot more of those online. We’re talking welcome packages, bonus bets, boosted odds, and loyalty rewards.

• Mobile Betting: You’ll get much greater betting flexibility online as you don’t have to be attached to an actual location. If you want to bet live on the go, you can do so through mobile sports betting sites, such as any of our top 10 picks today.

If you want to try something in between sports betting, check out our guide to the best NY online casinos.

New York Sports Betting Sites – FAQ

What is the Best Betting Site in NY?

According to our rankings, BetOnline is the best betting site in New York. Here, you will find competitive odds on popular and less-popular events, claim a $1,000 welcome bonus, and receive your winnings instantly.

Is Sports Betting Legal in New York?

Yes, sports betting is legal in New York. The bill for the legalization of sports betting was passed in the state back in 2022. This means that you can participate in online gambling without the need to worry about safety issues.

Which Sports Teams Can I Bet On in New York?

You can bet on the New York Yankees, the New York Rangers, the New York Giants, the New York Jets, in-state college teams… the list goes on.

We recommend opting for New York sports teams that play the sport you know best about so that you can be more clued up to place bets that have a greater chance of winning.

Do New York Sportsbooks Offer Mobile Betting?

Yes, New York sportsbooks do offer mobile betting. Some have dedicated apps while others make their sites compatible with modern iOS and Android smartphones. You can start betting with mobile devices at any of our recommended sites.

Comparing the Top 5 Best Betting Sites in New York

Ready to get started? Before you do that, take a look back with us at the top sports betting operators in New York.

BetOnline: We don’t doubt that this is the best sports betting site in New York. There’s a lot to love here, including up to a $1,000 welcome bonus for all new bettors.

BetWhale: You can get a lot more for your money at BetWhale than just about all other NY sportsbooks. They’re offering a 125% up to a $1,250 deposit bonus to everyone who signs up at their site.

Everygame: Baseball fans are going to love the huge range of markets and competitive odds at Everygame. You can even get a strong 100% match up to $500 when you sign up with the code WELCOME500.

Sportsbetting.ag: The best place for live betting in New York is Sportsbetting.ag thanks to their immersive in-game tools and fantastic website design. Plus, you can double your first two deposits up to $500.

Wild.io: If you like the sound of crypto sports betting then be sure to check out the huge range of crypto banking options and the super fast payouts at Wild.io. Make sure to grab a 100% match up to $200 when you create an account here.

Expert Tips for Wagering at New York Sports Betting Sites

Choosing a NY sports betting site is one thing but having an enjoyable experience is another. Here are a few tips from our team of experts, so you can stay on the happy side of gamblers:

Keep an Eye On Player and Team Form

It’s always best to bet based on the previous form of players and teams. Consider taking a look at previous results and studying how well each team or player performs against others to make sure you’re giving yourself the best chance of winning your bets.

Read Up on the Different Betting Types

There’s a lot of jargon that comes with online sports betting, such as ‘same game parlays’, ‘moneyline’, ‘over/under’, and more. Whether you bet on politics or soccer, we recommend researching these terms as they could help you to get more out of your online sportsbook experience.

Read the Bonus Terms and Conditions

Always read the terms and conditions for any bonuses, as you’ll need to know about rollovers, minimum odds, and time limits. That way, you’ll minimize the risk of losing out on your bonus cash.

Make Multiple New York Sports Betting Account

The bookies we’ve picked out today all have fantastic welcome bonus offers and nothing is preventing you from checking them all out. You could be getting all kinds of promotions and more while you figure out which sportsbook to stick with.

Make Sure to Gamble Responsibly

Always practice responsible gambling when you’re playing online. Consider using deposit limits to help you stay in control and then look into self-exclusion periods whenever you ever feel like things are beginning to get on top of you.

For more tips and tricks, check out our SC sportsbook guide.

So, What are the Best Sports Betting Sites in New York?

New York may well be the best state for sports betting, and our list of the top bookmakers in the state goes a long way to prove that.

The pick of the bunch has to be BetOnline for us as it offers the most competitive odds, the best range of markets, the most impressive bonuses, and fantastic live betting tools.

But then again, the likes of other NY sportsbooks are very close behind, so we recommend trying them to find the best option.

 

DISCLAIMER: The information on this site is for entertainment purposes only. Gambling, in any form, is a risky endeavor. With this in mind, we don’t have to remind you that “Responsible Gambling” must be practiced at all times.

If you feel you’re developing a gambling problem, call the National Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700. Speaking with a professional is the first step you can take to solve your gambling problem. 

All casino sites and their offerings are for those aged 21 and above. Check out these websites for free gambling addiction resources: